Organoids: technological innovation and ethical controversies

CHEN Qianwen; ZHAO Siqi; PENG Yaojin

doi:10.12211/2096-8280.2024-009

您当前的位置：

首页 >

文章列表页 >

Organoids: technological innovation and ethical controversies

Research Article | 更新时间：2025-03-19

- Organoids: technological innovation and ethical controversies
- Synthetic Biology Journal Vol. 5, Issue 4, Pages: 898-907(2024)
- 作者机构：
  
  1.中国科学院动物研究所，北京 100101
  2.北京干细胞与再生医学研究院，北京 100101
- 作者简介：
- 基金信息：
- DOI：10.12211/2096-8280.2024-009
  CLC： Q816
- Received：17 January 2024，
  
  Revised：2024-05-24，
  
  Published：31 August 2024
- 稿件说明：
移动端阅览
陈倩文，赵思琪，彭耀进. 类器官：技术创新与伦理争议［J］. 合成生物学， 2024， 5（4）： 898-907

CHEN Qianwen， ZHAO Siqi， PENG Yaojin. Organoids： technological innovation and ethical controversies［J］. Synthetic Biology Journal， 2024， 5（4）： 898-907
陈倩文，赵思琪，彭耀进. 类器官：技术创新与伦理争议［J］. 合成生物学， 2024， 5（4）： 898-907 DOI： 10.12211/2096-8280.2024-009.

CHEN Qianwen， ZHAO Siqi， PENG Yaojin. Organoids： technological innovation and ethical controversies［J］. Synthetic Biology Journal， 2024， 5（4）： 898-907 DOI： 10.12211/2096-8280.2024-009.

摘要

类器官技术，通过利用干细胞在体外培养构建的三维（3D）微型器官模型，模拟人体器官的结构及功能，已在疾病建模、药物筛选等生物医药领域得到广泛应用。然而，该前沿领域的快速发展亦引发一系列伦理问题，这些问题的解决对于促进领域的规范化与合法化发展至关重要。本文首先解析类器官技术的发展历程，并探讨其特征与应用价值。当前，类器官技术正逐步向构建更复杂的器官系统、实现更高仿真度及与其他技术的深度融合方向发展。考虑到人源类器官的特殊性、复杂性及敏感性，重点深入探讨了伴随技术进展而出现的伦理挑战，包括捐赠者的知情同意、隐私保护、技术的可及性，以及在模拟敏感器官（如大脑和胚胎）时所涉及的道德地位问题。国际组织与主要发达国家已在类器官研究的伦理治理方面采取了多项措施，通过发布伦理指南或标准，从多个维度应对类器官领域的伦理问题。相比之下，我国在这一领域尚未出台相关的立法政策。最后，本文提出了从评估量表的设计原则、评估标准的制定、量化方法、实施与监管、持续评估与反馈等要素构建“道德评估量表”框架，并建议加强跨学科合作，完善知情同意流程，以及建立国际统一的伦理准则。此外，支持伦理研究和公共讨论也是确保类器官技术负责任发展的关键措施。通过深入探讨类器官技术带来的伦理挑战及其应对之策，旨在促进科技创新与伦理关切之间的平衡，推动类器官领域的负责任创新，以更好地服务于人类健康和福祉。

Abstract

Organoid technology

which leverages the cultivation of three-dimensional (3D) miniature organ models from stem cells

in vitro

to simulate the structure and function of human organs

has emerged as a cornerstone in biomedical fields such as disease modeling and drug screening. Despite its significant contributions

the rapid advancement of this frontier technology also raises profound ethical challenges

necessitating a robust framework for its normalization and legalization. This paper firstly provides a comprehensive analysis of the development of organoid technology

elucidating its distinctive characteristics and substantial value in biomedical applications. Currently

the technology is advancing towards the construction of more complex organ systems

achieving higher fidelity

and integrating more intricately with other cutting-edge technologies. This evolution enhances the capability of organoids to mimic human physiology accurately

thereby improving the predictive accuracy of medical research and pharmaceutical developments. The paper examines the primary ethical challenges raised by organoid technology

including the informed consent of dono

privacy protection

and equitable access to this technology. These issues are pivotal in maintaining public trust and compliance with ethical norms. Additionally

it explores the ethical implications of modeling sensitive organs such as the brain and embryos

raising questions about the moral status of such models and potential psychological impacts on society. It also reviews how various countries and international organizations respond to these ethical controversies. Major developed countries and international bodies have adopted a variety of governance measures

primarily in the form of ethical guidelines or standards

which provide a flexible yet sometimes insufficient framework for addressing rapidly evolving technologies. In contrast

China lacks specific legislative policies regarding organoid technology

indicating a need for tailored governance strategies that align with both international standards and local ethical considerations. In order to bridge these gaps

this paper attempts to construct a “moral assessment scale” framework. This tool is designed to quantify ethical considerations and guide decision-making in organoid research and application. The paper advocates for strengthened interdisciplinary cooperation and the improvement of the informed consent process

essential for ethical compliance. Moreover

establishing an international unified ethical code could facilitate global cooperation and harmonize standards across borders. Supporting ethical research and fostering public discussions are also crucial for the responsible development of organoid technologies. By thoroughly examining the ethical challenges and proposing actionable solutions

this paper aims to foster a balance between scientific innovation and ethical responsibility. This balanced approach will not only advance the field but also ensure that it develops in a manner respecting human dignity and societal values

ultimately better serving human health and well-being.

关键词

Keywords

references

BARTFELD S , CLEVERS H . Stem cell-derived organoids and their application for medical research and patient treatment [J ] . Journal of Molecular Medicine , 2017 , 95 ( 7 ): 729 - 738 .

Method of the year 2017: organoids [J ] . Nature Methods , 2018 , 15 : 1 .

The United States Congress . S . 5002 (117th): FDA Modernization Act 2.0 [R/OL ] . 2022[ 2024-01-01 ] . https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/5002 https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/5002 .

CORRÒ C , NOVELLASDEMUNT L , LI V S W . A brief history of organoids [J ] . American Journal of Physiology Cell Physiology , 2020 , 319 ( 1 ): C151 - C165 .

CHUAI M L , SERRANO NÁJERA G , SERRA M , et al . Reconstruction of distinct vertebrate gastrulation modes via modulation of key cell behaviors in the chick embryo [J ] . Science Advances , 2023 , 9 ( 1 ): eabn5429 .

ROSSBACH P , BÖHME H J , LANGE S , et al . Model-based prediction of an effective adhesion parameter guiding multi-type cell segregation [J ] . Entropy , 2021 , 23 ( 11 ): 1378 .

CHO L T , WAMAITHA S E , TSAI I J , et al . Conversion from mouse embryonic to extra-embryonic endoderm stem cells reveals distinct differentiation capacities of pluripotent stem cell states [J ] . Development , 2012 , 139 ( 16 ): 2866 - 2877 .

LUDWIG T E , KUJAK A , RAUTI A , et al . 20 years of human pluripotent stem cell research: it all started with five lines [J ] . Cell Stem Cell , 2018 , 23 ( 5 ): 644 - 648 .

XIANG G H , WANG H Y . Extended pluripotent stem cells facilitate mouse model generation [J ] . Protein & Cell , 2019 , 10 ( 1 ): 5 - 7 .

SATO T , VRIES R G , SNIPPERT H J , et al . Single Lgr5 stem cells build crypt-villus structures in vitro without a mesenchymal niche [J ] . Nature , 2009 , 459 ( 7244 ): 262 - 265 .

张秀梅 , 翟运开 , 赵杰 , 等 . 类器官模型国内外数据库近10年文献研究热点分析 [J ] . 中国组织工程研究 , 2021 , 25 ( 8 ): 1249 - 1255 .

ZHANG X M , ZHAI Y K , ZHAO J , et al . Research hotspots of organoid models in recent 10 years: a search in domestic and foreign databases [J ] . Chinese Journal of Tissue Engineering Research , 2021 , 25 ( 8 ): 1249 - 1255 .

SAWAI T , SAKAGUCHI H , THOMAS E , et al . The ethics of cerebral organoid research: being conscious of consciousness [J ] . Stem Cell Reports , 2019 , 13 ( 3 ): 440 - 447 .

GILAZIEVA Z , PONOMAREV A , RUTLAND C , et al . Promising applications of tumor spheroids and organoids for personalized medicine [J ] . Cancers , 2020 , 12 ( 10 ): 2727 .

BREDENOORD A L , CLEVERS H , KNOBLICH J A . Human tissues in a dish: the research and ethical implications of organoid technology [J ] . Science , 2017 , 355 ( 6322 ): eaaf9414 .

ZHU L L , FAN Y H , HUANG X M , et al . Patent bibliometric analysis for global trend of organoid technologies in the past decade [J ] . iScience , 2022 , 25 ( 8 ): 104728 .

VELASCO S , PAULSEN B , ARLOTTA P . 3D brain organoids: studying brain development and disease outside the embryo [J ] . Annual Review of Neuroscience , 2020 , 43 : 375 - 389 .

BIREY F , ANDERSEN J , MAKINSON C D , et al . Assembly of functionally integrated human forebrain spheroids [J ] . Nature , 2017 , 545 ( 7652 ): 54 - 59 .

李德新 , 朱祺 . 培养皿中的大脑模型: 人脑类器官研究的伦理问题探讨 [J ] . 自然辩证法通讯 , 2024 , 46 ( 4 ): 84 - 91 .

LI D X , ZHU Q . The brain model in a petri dish: ethical issues in the study of human brain organoids [J ] . Journal of Dialectics of Nature , 2024 , 46 ( 4 ): 84 - 91 .

罗会宇 , 马永慧 . 人脑类器官的道德地位问题 [J ] . 自然辩证法研究 , 2023 , 39 ( 5 ): 75 - 80 .

LUO H Y , MA Y H . Issues on moral status of human brain organoids [J ] . Studies in Dialectics of Nature , 2023 , 39 ( 5 ): 75 - 80 .

LAVAZZA A , MASSIMINI M . Cerebral organoids: ethical issues and consciousness assessment [J ] . Journal of Medical Ethics , 2018 , 44 ( 9 ): 606 - 610 .

BAHADUR G , MORRISON M , MACHIN L . Beyond the ‘embryo question’: human embryonic stem cell ethics in the context of biomaterial donation in the UK [J ] . Reproductive Biomedicine Online , 2010 , 21 ( 7 ): 868 - 874 .

杨洁 , 张弛 , 李天晴 . 探秘生命之初:类胚胎的研究革命与伦理探究 [J ] . 科学 , 2024 , 76 ( 2 ): 8 - 11, 4 .

YANG J , ZHANG C , LI T Q . Exploring the origin of life: revolutionary research on embryoids and ethical inquiry [J ] . Science , 2024 , 76 ( 2 ): 8 - 11, 4 .

MANSOUR A A , GONÇALVES J T , BLOYD C W , et al . An in vivo model of functional and vascularized human brain organoids [J ] . Nature Biotechnology , 2018 , 36 ( 5 ): 432 - 441 .

DING L L , XIAO Z Y , GONG X , et al . Knowledge graphs of ethical concerns of cerebral organoids [J ] . Cell Proliferation , 2022 , 55 ( 8 ): e13239 .

FARAHANY N A , GREELY H T , HYMAN S , et al . The ethics of experimenting with human brain tissue [J ] . Nature , 2018 , 556 ( 7702 ): 429 - 432 .

MARSEE A , ROOS F J M , VERSTEGEN M M A , et al . Building consensus on definition and nomenclature of hepatic, pancreatic, and biliary organoids [J ] . Cell Stem Cell , 2021 , 28 ( 5 ): 816 - 832 .

PAȘCA S P , ARLOTTA P , BATEUP H S , et al . A nomenclature consensus for nervous system organoids and assembloids [J ] . Nature , 2022 , 609 ( 7929 ): 907 - 910 .

HEINEMANN T , HONNEFELDER L . Principles of ethical decision making regarding embryonic stem cell research in Germany [J ] . Bioethics , 2002 , 16 ( 6 ): 530 - 543 .

JEPSON A , MOSTYN B , HARGREAVE T B , et al . Human fertilisation and embryology bill [J ] . British Medical Journal , 1990 , 300 ( 6741 ): 1721 - 1722 .

中国细胞生物学学会 . 人干细胞研究伦理审查技术规范:T/C SCB 0001—2022 [S ] . 北京 : 中国标准出版社 , 2020 : 8 .

Chinese Society for Cell Biology . Technical specification for ethical review of human stem cell research: T/C SCB 0001—2022 [S ] . Beijing : China Standards Press , 2020 : 8 .

罗会宇 , 马永慧 . 人源类器官的应用前景、伦理风险与治理建议 [J ] . 科技导报 , 2022 , 40 ( 8 ): 6 - 13 .

LUO H Y , MA Y H . Application prospect and ethical risk of human organoids research [J ] . Science & Technology Review , 2022 , 40 ( 8 ): 6 - 13 .

MOLLAKI V . Ethical challenges in organoid use [J ] . Biotech , 2021 , 10 ( 3 ): 12 .

Views

下载量

CSCD

Alert me when the article has been cited

提交

Tools

Publicity Resources

Research progress on Lgr5-mediated stem cell regulation and digestive system organoid formation

The construction approaches and biomaterials for vascularized organoids

Early human embryo development and stem cells

Related Author

CHEN Qianwen

ZHAO Siqi

PENG Yaojin

HE Liuqin

YIN Yulong

LI Xing

YAO Tuoxin

YU Shuang

Related Institution

Beijing Institute for Stem Cell and Regenerative Medicine

Hunan Provincial Key Laboratory of Animal Intestinal Function and Regulation， Hunan International Joint Laboratory of Animal Intestinal Ecology and Health， College of Life Sciences， Hunan Normal University

Interdisciplinary Science Center， Institute of Zoology， Chinese Academy of Sciences

Hunan Provincial Key Laboratory of Animal Nutritional Physiology and Metabolic Process， National Engineering Laboratory for Pollution Control and Waste Utilization in Livestock and Poultry Production， Institute of Subtropical Agriculture， Chinese Academy of Sciences

School of Biomedical Engineering （Suzhou）， Division of Life Science and Medicine， University of Science and Technology of China

⁰